
What actually works in lead generation for mortgage brokers
The home loan and refinance leads that book appointments are usually the ones that have been filtered before they reach you. They arrive with a clear loan purpose, a rough loan size, a timeframe and consent to be contacted. Then they get a fast, organised follow-up.
Cheap clicks and a high lead count rarely help on their own. What matters is how many leads become booked appointments, and how many of those become settled loans.
There is demand to compete for. Brokers facilitated a record 81.6% of all new residential home loans in the June 2026 quarter, according to the MFAA. At the same time, the number of new loan commitments for dwellings fell 15.0% in the September quarter 2026, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics, so each purchase borrower is worth handling well.
This guide covers what a qualified lead should include, the questions that cut out time-wasters, speed to lead, Meta lead forms versus landing pages, measuring cost per settled loan, your options for getting leads, and compliance. If you are new to the topic, start with our guide to lead generation.
Why generic leads waste a broker's time
Most broker lead generation fails at qualification and follow-up, not at the ad. The common problems:
- Unqualified leads. A name and phone number with no loan purpose, budget or timeframe means the first call is spent working out whether the person is even a borrower.
- Shared or recycled leads. When the same enquiry goes to several businesses, the borrower gets rung repeatedly and is less likely to engage. Ask any supplier directly whether their leads are shared.
- Slow follow-up. Leads that arrive in an email batch or sit in an inbox lose interest, however keen they were when they enquired.
- Missing context. Without the answers the person gave, you can't tailor the first call or decide who to ring first.
What a qualified mortgage broker lead should include
A useful lead gives you enough to have a focused first conversation:
- Loan purpose: purchase, refinance or equity release.
- Loan size range: a range rather than an exact figure, so the person is comfortable answering.
- Employment type: for example PAYG or self-employed, because it shapes the conversation you need to have.
- Deposit or available equity: again as a range.
- Timeframe: buying or refinancing soon, or still researching.
- Contact details and clear consent to be contacted by you.
These are screening details for your first call. They are not an assessment of whether anyone qualifies for a loan.
Qualifying questions that cut out time-wasters
A few well-chosen questions in the form filter out people who aren't ready, without making the form so long that good borrowers drop off. Useful question types include:
- What are you looking to do: buy, refinance or access equity?
- Roughly how much do you want to borrow?
- When are you hoping to move?
- How are you employed?
- Would you like a broker to call you?
The wording of the ad and the questions decides who answers. At Earng Media we build funnels on buyer psychology, using the four DISC buying archetypes, so the ad and the questions are written to attract and filter for the right borrowers.
There is a balance. Too few questions lets time-wasters through, and too many cuts volume. The right mix depends on your offer and market, so test it and review it regularly.
Speed to lead: why follow-up decides whether a lead books
Interest fades after someone enquires, so the gap between the enquiry and your first contact matters. A good lead left for days often behaves like a poor one.

Practical steps:
- Send leads straight into your CRM or a shared sheet, not an inbox.
- Decide who calls each lead.
- Treat new leads as a priority during business hours.
- Follow a set sequence of calls and messages for people who don't answer.
- Use the qualifying answers on the first call, so the borrower feels heard rather than re-interviewed.
Follow-up over time matters too. The MFAA found 52% of buyers who had used or would consider using a broker had contacted, or would contact, one before looking for a property. Someone who is still researching today may be ready later.
Your team takes the call. Earng Media handles the ad, capture, qualifying, booking and delivery, but we don't close the deal.
Meta lead forms or landing pages: which suits brokers?
Meta instant lead forms are low friction because details can pre-fill. That can lift volume, but it can also let in less committed enquiries unless you add qualifying questions.
Landing pages give more room to explain the offer, build trust and ask qualifying questions. They usually take more effort per enquiry, which can mean fewer but more intentional leads.
Neither is always better. It depends on the offer, the audience and how fast your team follows up, and many brokers test both. Our Marketing platform runs Meta ads, creative, social, SEO and landing pages from your brand kit.
Measure cost per settled loan, not just cost per lead
Cost per lead is easy to see in the ads manager, but it says nothing about which leads booked, applied or settled.
Track each CRM stage:
- Lead
- Contacted
- Appointment booked
- Application
- Settled
Then work out the cost at each stage by campaign and by ad. This shows which ads bring borrowers who settle, even if their cost per lead looks higher.
Our Reporting product puts ad spend and CRM outcomes in one live report, showing cost per lead and the cost of every CRM stage by campaign and ad. You can see what every lead became. Results still vary by campaign, offer and market.
Buying leads, running your own ads or using an agency
Buying leads. You pay for leads rather than clicks, and it's quicker to start, though you have less control over creative. With Your Pay Per Lead, you buy leads with credit and they're delivered to your CRM, Google Sheet or webhook with every qualifying answer attached. You can see each campaign and its qualifying questions before buying, top up by card with no lock-in, and dispute a lead when the wrong person answers. Read how Pay Per Lead works.
Pay per lead changes where the risk sits, but it doesn't remove marketing risk. Lead quality and conversion still depend on the market, the offer and your follow-up.
Running your own ads. Full control and learning, but it needs time, creative, tracking and budget to test.
Using an agency. Hands-off campaign management. Ask how they report on outcomes past the lead stage.
Whichever you choose, ask:
- What qualifying questions are used?
- How are leads delivered?
- Are leads shared with other businesses?
- How do disputes work?
- How are results reported beyond cost per lead?
Your compliance obligations stay with you
Whoever generates the lead, you keep your own obligations under privacy law, spam rules, the Do Not Call Register and your NCCP and credit licensing obligations.
The ACMA is clear that it is each business's responsibility to make sure consent has been obtained before sending marketing messages. Check that the consent wording on forms covers the contact you plan to make, and keep records.
Ads and follow-up messages also need to meet your licensing and advertising obligations. Check with your licensee or compliance adviser. This is a general reminder, not legal advice.
How Earng Media runs lead generation for brokers
Earng Media is a Brisbane lead-generation company founded by Jackson Earngey. We've run lead generation since 2022 across 13 industries, including mortgage brokers, investment property, superannuation, insurance agencies and buyers agents. Everything runs through three in-house products: Your Pay Per Lead, Reporting and Marketing.
One client who started with us in October 2023 with one salesperson recorded $1.2M in sales from $108K of ad spend, an 11x return on ad spend. That is one client's result, not a typical outcome or a promise. You can read our Google reviews, where we have 23 five-star reviews.
We're not a CRM and we don't close sales. We run the ad, capture, qualifying, booking and delivery, and your team takes the call.
To see the campaigns and qualifying questions we use for brokers, book a demo with us.
This article is general information only and does not take your business's circumstances into account. Results vary by industry, offer and market.
Sources
- Mortgage broker market share reaches record 81.6%, Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA), 2 September 2026
- Lending indicators, September Quarter 2026, Australian Bureau of Statistics, 11 November 2026
- Australian Borrower Report 2026 reveals how buyers are using AI and building trust with mortgage brokers, Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA), 16 November 2026
- Telemarketing and e-marketing – common issues and mistakes, Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA)
- ASIC Report 840: What the review means for mortgage brokers, Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA), 12 October 2026
Frequently asked questions
Are Facebook and Instagram leads any good for mortgage brokers?
They can be, when the ad and form include qualifying questions about loan purpose, loan size range, timeframe and consent, and when leads are followed up quickly. Without those, Meta leads tend to include more casual enquiries.
How quickly should I call a new home loan or refinance lead?
As soon as you reasonably can during business hours. Interest fades after someone enquires, so route leads straight into your CRM, assign who calls, and follow a set sequence for people who don't answer.
How much should a mortgage broker lead cost?
There is no set figure, as it depends on your market, offer, targeting and qualifying questions. A more useful measure is the cost per booked appointment and per settled loan, tracked by campaign and ad.
What happens if a bought lead turns out to be the wrong person?
With Your Pay Per Lead, you can dispute a lead when the wrong person answers. With any supplier, ask how disputes work before you buy.
Do I still have privacy, spam and Do Not Call obligations if I buy leads?
Yes. Your privacy, spam, Do Not Call and NCCP and credit licensing obligations stay with you. Check consent wording, keep records and speak with your licensee or compliance adviser.
Written by the Earng Media team← All articles



